Naturepedic Mattress Review – 3 Months After Purchase

Naturepedic organic mattress

One of the benefits of having sold our rental house earlier this year was that it freed up some cash that we could use on some “deferred” items we haven't been able to purchase. Buying a mattress was on the top of that list.

Ever since my wife quit her job due to some health-related issues, she has been on a quest to feel better. One of the more helpful paths she has taken was to change her diet. But she has always struggled with getting good sleep.

So, finding a mattress that met her needs and was able to give her a good nights rest, has taken some time.

Our first introduction to Naturepedic

In doing her research for mattresses that were highly rated and also health-conscience – my wife first heard about Naturepedic through their website. Naturepedic is one of the only manufacturers that produces an organic product, free of some of the chemicals found in most mattresses.

Their founder, Barry Cik – an environmental engineer – was looking for a baby crib mattress for his new grandchild. But, he couldn't find anything that didn't use many of the harmful chemicals and products in the manufacturing process.

“I knew all about vinyl/PVC, polyurethane foam, and the various chemicals contained in them, and there was no way I was going to put my grandchild to sleep within a few inches of these chemicals.” Cik stated on the company's website.

Cik soon set out to manufacture a mattress that was non-toxic / organic and founded Naturepedic. The company created the first and only waterproof organic baby crib mattress designed with a patented food-grade polyethylene cover, which is made without harmful chemicals and meets food-contact standards.

They soon after began creating adult mattresses with these same standards. Each one is individually manufactured by Amish craftsmen in Ohio.

The purchase

About a year ago, one of my wife's good friends began working at a Naturepedic gallery store (which are few and far between – yet we happen to live close to one). She alerted us to a sale that was going on where you could get free bedding + pillows with the purchase of a mattress.

So, we set out to explore what they had to offer.

It was a quaint store that was inviting and (surprisingly) free of the usual scents that you find at other mattress stores. It had a welcoming atmosphere with a single aisle and mattresses laid out on each side.

Our friend greeted us and began talking a bit more about the company and their mattresses. We tried out several beds – all were very comfortable – and settled on a queen-sized, pillow-top mattress.

Having slept on a futon for many of my young-adult days and spongy mattresses from college dorm days, I could sleep on most anything that wasn't a hard floor. My wife's tastes were a bit more discerning.

Our mattress was on the higher end of Naturepedic's offering – but we knew this was another investment in our health and realized it would likely last us for years to come.

The EOS mattress we purchased has a 20-year limited warranty, with the first 10 years being a full component repair / replacement. The last 10 years are prorated based on a 50/5 percentage basis. Also, within 90 days of the purchase, we can swap out our pillow top for free (plus shipping).

naturepedic mattress bed
Our Naturepedic EOS Pillow-top Queen mattress in all its glory.

Read what TTG reader, Jason, had to say about his Saatva mattress experience.

The verdict

So it has been over three months now since our purchase and use of the EOS queen mattress we purchased. And, so far, my wife loves it.

One of the first things we noticed when it was getting set-up in our bedroom was there were no smells. I'm accustomed to smelling some off-gassing from a mattress – but there was no hint of it.

I'm very pleased it is meeting her needs and I agree, that it is probably one of the best mattresses I've ever slept on. We did have some issues with getting a box spring set-up and the bed has been a little too high to get up on (my wife actually uses a foot-stool to jump on-board). We're probably going to get rid of the box spring at some point and opt for a board underneath instead.


I also think we could have gotten a king mattress instead because more room would be beneficial to both parties. I sometimes feel like the Mrs. has 3/4 of the bed (don't tell her I said that). 

All-in-all, it has been a good purchase for us and would recommend Naturepedic to those who are chemically sensitive and want a top-of-the-line mattress.


  • High quality
  • Organic, toxic-free
  • Excellent warranty


  • Cost
  • Not many store locations yet

Have you had any experience with Naturepedic? What mattress do you have?

Check out Naturepedic beds

Update 5/31/18: Naturepedic announced a “Layer Swap” program whereby if you don't like your layers within 90 days of purchase, you can swap them out. See their website via link above for more details.

TTG may receive a commission on any purchase that you make through our links – at no cost to you. 

Other mattresses

Mattress CompanyStarting PriceFirmnessAvailability
Naturepedic$1,199VariousIn-store / online
Nectar$399 (when on sale)Medium-firmOnline

Naturepedic Mattresses




Customer Service







  • High quality
  • Chemical-free
  • Customizable
  • Warranty
  • USA made


  • Cost
  • Not many locations

You might also be interested in:

Recommended Posts


  1. It’s very hard to believe that you honestly report there were no smells. The EOS that I ordered stinks to high heaven. I’ve been airing it out with a fan for a week and still can’t sleep on it. I’m accustomed to sleeping on wool… wool comforter, wool pillows, wool batting in my current mattress, and have had no odor issues with these, but the smell of the Naturepedic is extremely intense. My friend had the same opinion.

  2. Thanks just got one. I’m swapping out the latex layer for a different firmness though. It is difficult to know what combo of firmness layers to go for. At least they let you do a layer swap when you realize it isn’t the correct firmness for you. You can get either medium or plush coils. Then you need to decide on firm, medium or soft latex on top.

  3. I bought this bed and have had it 6 months and have had a lot of upper backaches. Had swapped out one layer thinking that would be the answer but it helped nothing. Of course by the time we figured out that it is now over the 90 day return policy it was too late to do anything. So sorry I made this very unwise investment. Spent over $5000 for a king and my husband and I think it would have been better to buy the toxic mattress for less because we probably would sleep better.

    • I’m wondering if you have the plush base coils. If your base coils are too soft, then there’s not much you can do. Maybe contact Naturepedic and see if they will allow an exchange if that’s the case.

      I woke up in severe pain, after I tried the plush latex on top and slept on my stomach. I tossed the plush and found that the medium coil over the medium latex over firm coil offered more support. I liked the snuggly feel of the plush, but I think that three inches of plush just allows you to sink to deeply. I think that three inches in the very top layer of the pillow-top is just too thick. I’m still in the layer exchange period, so hoping to find a combination that works.

      • … lower back pain.

  4. Did you check out the Berkeley ergonomics mattress or Charles P Rogers mattress prior to your purchase?

  5. Thanks so much for posting this! We recently ordered a Naturepedic mattress (the exact one shown in the picture above) and are very eagerly awaiting its arrival! It has been quite a journey finding this bed. We started with the Dream Bed memory foam mattress (just for a 90 day trial period), then almost bought a Tempurpedic, but stopped the delivery once we learned about all the chemicals. Then I did tons of research which led me to the amazing company of Naturepedic. Do you still love your Naturepedic mattress?? I am so excited for ours to arrive!! :)

    • Hi Kristin – yes, we are still enjoying ours. My side may be a little too soft – but it’s holding its own after 6 months now. Good friends of ours just bought a new mattress from them and they love it. The guy has back problems and said it was the best night sleeps hes had in years. Not having the off-gassing too is a plus. Would love to hear how you like yours.

      • what firmness levels are your layers?

  6. We will be in the market for a new mattress pretty soon so we’ll check this out. Thanks for sharing Aaron!

    • Love to hear what you get!

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *